On a cold December morning in 2000, Mike Williams left for a duck hunting trip at Lake Seminole and never came home. Authorities believed he drowned. His family was told it was a tragic accident. Case closed, right? When other evidence, con...

Trigger warning: This episode discusses domestic violence and sexual assault.In 1993, the name Lorena Bobbitt became a cultural punchline. But behind the headlines and late-night jokes was a far more serious story.In this e...

This week on Crimenelia Street, we sail straight into the legend of pirate José Gaspar, the man (or myth?) behind the annual pirate invasion of Tampa, Gasparilla. And because no trip to Florida is complete without some nonsense, Tori and Sam pl...

In Episode 29 of Crimenelia Street, Sam walks Tori through one of the most unsettling unsolved cases in American true crime history: the Springfield Three. What begins as a night meant to celebrate quickly turns into a mystery—no forced entry, ...

This week we’re getting into some vigilante shit. Faye Yager didn’t trust the courts to protect children—so she built her own underground. Children of the Underground became a secret network for parents fleeing alleged abuse, moving families ac...